John Shaw Nature & Digital Photography Workshops
Click here for locations and dates
Mexico's Colonial Heartland
March 17–24, 2007
Horses and Icons of the Wild West
August 26–September 1, 2007
Masai Mara Wildlife Reserve, Kenya
September 7–21, 2007
Australia Wildlife
November 1–20, 2007
Ive recently received several E-mails asking about photographing subjects silhouetted against a light background. Such photos are actually extremely simple to do, if you deal with two major problems: correctly exposing the film and watching for tonal merges.

Many photographers have trouble with silhouetted subjects because they try to meter the scene just as they have composed it, especially when their cameras are set to an auto exposure mode using matrix metering. The meter reads all the dark area in the frame and tries to compensate the exposure. All too often the result is an overexposed photo with the light areas of the scene burned out. The solution is to change your working methods.



First set your camera to the manual exposure mode and change the metering pattern to spot metering. (About 90% of the time I work in manual exposure/spot, regardless of the subject Im photographing. I want to be in charge of my photography and not let the camera make all the decisions.) You now need to be careful in choosing the correct area of the scene to meter, and then work in stop increments to place that area as the tone you want it to appear on film. Remember, you can make any portion of your picture appear as any tone you want it to be. You are not recording the "reality" of the scene you see, since reality and photography are two different worlds. What you want to ask yourself is not "What tone is this?" but rather "What tone do I want to record this as?"

Slide film can record detail in a spread of five stops, as Ive discussed in previous columns. A spot meter reading will give you the base exposure values to use in order to render the subject you metered as a medium tone, regardless of what the metered areas tonality is in reality. Open up one stop from this meter reading and that subject will record on film as a "light" tonality. Open up two stops and you get an "extremely light" recording. Stop down one stop and it will be "dark." Stop down two stops and it will be "extremely dark."

So, when working a silhouette situation, the first order of business is not to meter the final composition. Instead, aim your spot meter at a clear portion of the background sky. (If the sun is in your frame, make sure you dont try to meter it!) This will be your base meter reading, your starting point. If you shoot at that exposure value; then that particular portion of the sky will be rendered as a medium tone in your photo. But you will rarely want to photograph with this medium tone placement, and Ill explain why in just a moment.

The best solutionand the way I work silhouettes almost all the timeis to place the background one stop lighter than medium by adding one stop of light to your base meter reading. This works particularly well when silhouetting a subject against the morning or evening sky.

Suppose you want to silhouette some trees against a beautiful twilight sky just after sunset. Find your shooting position, determine your focal length, and then aim your camera at the open sky slightly above the horizon and meter this area. Lets assume your meter says 1/30 second at f/11. Re-compose the scene exactly as you want it to appear, and then open up the exposure by one stop to 1/15 second at f/11. By doing this you ensure that the trees silhouetted in the foreground do not disappear tonally into the sky.

If you make the sky "medium" by shooting at the direct meter reading your silhouette wont show up nearly as well. This is particularly true when youre working silhouetted subjects using a wide-angle lens. When shooting silhouettes you are almost always working on axis with the light source; youre shooting against the brightest part of the sky. Since a wide-angle lens encompasses such a wide angle of view, the edges of the frame will be much darker than the center portion since they are off-axis to the light source. Place the background sky as a medium and your silhouetted objects will disappear into the background. Place the background as "light" and the silhouette will show up better.

Dont worry about the foreground becoming lighter. You can easily predict exactly how it will appear. Heres the process: Meter the background sky and place it as a "light" tone by opening up one stop from your base meter reading. Now swing your camera down to the foreground and take another meter reading. Count how many stops there are between the two meter readings. Since there is less light on the foreground, it will appear that many stops darker than the sky.

For example, lets go back to those trees silhouetted against the twilight sky. Youre going to actually shoot at an exposure of 1/15 second at f/11 to make the sky "light." Now meter the foreground (which is exactly the same as metering the side of the trees facing you since both are receiving the same amount of light). The meter now says 2 seconds at f/11. How many stops are there between 1/8 second and 2 seconds? Five. Expose the sky as a "light" tone and the foreground (the trees, that is) will be five stops darker in tonality, which drops the trees off the bottom of the tonal scale. They will record as pure black.



Lets try a simple silhouette, soap tree yucca against the twilight sky from White Sands National Monument, done with an 80-200mm lens. Heres the shot:



Heres where I spot metered the scene:



Working with your camera set in the manual exposure mode and spot metering is the easiest way to photograph silhouettes as you can precisely meter one specific area, set the exposure, then let go of the camera and lens. While you can work with auto exposure and other metering patternssetting the AE compensation to a +1 and holding it lockedwhy do things the hard way when the easy way is so much simpler?



Heres a photo of Balanced Rock in Arches National Park:



So where did I spot meter this composition? I spot metered at the arrow location and opened up one stop.



Watch out for tonal merges, where the silhouetted subjects appear to overlap into one. We have three-dimensional vision, but film has only two. We know that those silhouettes are really of several subjects, but film does not. When you overlap silhouettes they blend into one giant subject. Pick your camera position carefully to avoid as many merging areas as possible.



For example, here is a photo of ocotillo and saguaro cactus in the Arizona desert:



Heres how I spot metered this scene:



And here are the potential merge areas that I had to consider:







Lets look at another example, a ghost gum at the Devils Marbles in the Australian Outback:



Heres where I spot metered and opened up:



And here are all the potential merges that I avoided by careful camera positioning:



Silhouettes are easy to photograph if you follow the steps Ive outlined below:

1. Set your camera to manual exposure and spot metering.

2. Meter what will be a bright area in the background and open up one stop.

3. Position your camera to avoid tonal merges.

Have fun!





Joseph Van Os Photo Safaris, Inc. P.O. Box 655, Vashon Island, Washington USA 98070
Phone: (206) 463-5383   Fax: (206) 463-5484    Email: info@photosafaris.com
Copyright © 2008, Joseph Van Os Photo Safaris, Inc.